In the last decade, mobile advertising has undergone a transformative evolution. What began as simple banner ads has become a sophisticated ecosystem where personalized, data-driven campaigns are the norm. The number of smartphone users is estimated to grow to a staggering 6.2 billion by 20291, making mobile devices the primary touchpoint for digital interaction and commerce. Advertisers have capitalized on this ubiquity by utilizing tools like Apple's Identifier for Advertisers (IDFA) to track user behavior across apps, deliver targeted ads, and measure campaign performance with remarkable precision.
However, this surge in personalized advertising has heightened concerns about user privacy. Recent surveys reveal that over 80% of consumers are worried about how companies use their personal data.2 Governments and regulatory bodies have also stepped in, introducing laws like the EU's General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) and the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) in the U.S. In response to consumer sentiment and regulatory pressures, tech giants like Apple are redefining how user data can be collected and used, ushering in a new era focused on privacy.
This article aims to demystify two critical components of this shift: Apple's IDFA and its privacy-focused successor, SKAD Network. We will delve into what these tools are, how they function, and the significant changes they bring to user acquisition strategies.
The Identifier for Advertisers (IDFA) is a unique, random identifier assigned by Apple to each iOS device. It functions like a digital passport for the device, allowing advertisers to track user interactions with apps and ads without accessing personal information. The IDFA is crucial for measuring advertising effectiveness, enabling attribution of app installations and in-app events back to specific ad campaigns.
When a user clicks on an ad and downloads an app, the IDFA helps link these actions together. Advertisers and app developers embed the IDFA into their analytics tools to monitor user behavior across different apps. This tracking facilitates accurate attribution models, allowing marketers to understand which campaigns are driving conversions and how users engage with their apps over time.
IDFA plays an important role in advertising by:
IDFA has been instrumental in delivering personalized advertising on iOS devices. By analyzing the IDFA-associated data, advertisers can create detailed user profiles based on app usage patterns, preferences, and behaviors. This information enables the delivery of highly relevant ads, increasing engagement rates and improving the overall user experience. For example, a user who frequently uses travel apps might receive targeted ads for flight deals or hotel discounts.
Cross-app tracking is essential for understanding the customer journey in a fragmented mobile landscape. IDFA allows advertisers to follow a user's interactions across multiple apps, providing insights into their interests and purchase intent. This capability enhances ad targeting accuracy and helps in retargeting campaigns, where users are shown ads based on previous interactions to encourage them to complete a desired action.
Before the release of iOS 14, access to the IDFA was granted by default unless users explicitly opted out through the "Limit Ad Tracking" setting in their device's privacy options. According to a study by AppsFlyer in 2020, only about 25% of users had enabled this setting3, leaving approximately three-quarters of iOS users available for IDFA-based tracking. This widespread availability made the IDFA a foundational tool for mobile advertisers.
Before the privacy changes introduced in iOS 14, the IDFA was embedded in nearly all facets of mobile advertising. It was estimated that close to 65% of mobile app install attribution relied on IDFA data, according to AppsFlyer3. Advertisers used it extensively for:
The IDFA's role was so integral that many ad networks and measurement platforms depended on it to function effectively. Its availability allowed for granular tracking and precise measurement, which are cornerstones of performance marketing.
In 2020, Apple took a monumental step by announcing App Tracking Transparency (ATT), a framework designed to give users more control over their personal information and how it's used by apps.
The journey toward ATT began at the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC) in June 2020. Apple unveiled iOS 14 and introduced ATT as a core feature, signaling a significant shift in data privacy standards. The company emphasized that apps would soon be required to obtain explicit user permission before tracking their data across other companies' apps and websites.
Under ATT, apps must present a standardized prompt asking users for permission to track their activity across other apps and websites. The prompt typically reads: "Allow [App Name] to track your activity across other companies' apps and websites?" You can see how the top-grossing games implemented the ATT prompt in our industry report.
This change flipped the default setting; previously, users had to opt out of tracking, but now apps had to secure an explicit opt-in. The result was a 55% decrease in the share of trackable data (from 73% to 18%) in the US and a 24% to 59% decrease in other countries4, drastically reducing the availability of user data for advertisers.
The advertising industry reacted strongly to ATT, voicing concerns over its impact on ad personalization and revenue. Companies like Meta argued that the changes could severely affect small businesses that rely on targeted advertising to reach customers. In their Q4 2020 earnings report, Facebook warned investors about potential revenue declines due to ATT5. Developers also faced challenges, fearing decreased ad monetization and the need to overhaul their user acquisition strategies.
On the other hand, public reaction to ATT was generally positive, with many users appreciating the increased control over their personal data. A survey by the Pew Research Center in 2021 found that nearly 80% of Americans were concerned about having very little or no control over their data, aligning with the principles behind ATT2.
SKAN or SKAdNetwork is Apple's privacy-focused framework designed to measure advertising campaign performance without compromising user privacy. Introduced in 2018 and significantly updated with iOS 14, it allows advertisers to attribute app installations and limited post-install events in a way that doesn't reveal individual user data.
Unlike IDFA-based tracking, which relies on a unique device identifier to monitor user behavior across apps, SKAN operates without accessing any personal or device-specific information. IDFA provides granular data that enables detailed user profiling and real-time optimization. In contrast, SKAN offers anonymized, delayed, and aggregated data, limiting the depth and immediacy of insights.
When a user interacts with an ad and subsequently installs an app, SKAdNetwork registers this conversion without exposing the user's identity. Here's how the process works:
The delayed and aggregated nature of the data ensures that individual user actions cannot be reverse-engineered, maintaining anonymity.
SKAN employs cryptographic techniques to validate the authenticity of conversion data. Each postback sent to the ad network includes a signature generated using Apple's private key. This signature confirms that the data originates from a legitimate source and hasn't been tampered with without accessing any personal information.
SKAdNetwork significantly enhances user privacy by:
These benefits bolster user trust and comply with global privacy regulations like GDPR and CCPA.
While SKAdNetwork addresses privacy concerns, it introduces several challenges for advertisers:
The enforcement of App Tracking Transparency (ATT) and SKAN has dramatically reduced advertisers' access to user-level data on iOS devices, meaning advertisers can no longer rely on detailed user profiles to inform their targeting strategies. The lack of granular data forces marketers to adopt broader audience segments, which can lead to less effective campaigns and lower engagement rates.
Lookalike audiences and retargeting campaigns have been particularly affected, as nearly 50% relied on view-through attribution data6. These strategies depend on rich user data to identify and reach individuals who resemble existing high-value customers or to re-engage users who have shown interest.
In terms of attribution, these changes present a two-fold challenge:
SKAN introduced a mandatory delay in data reporting to enhance user privacy. Postbacks are sent to ad networks after a randomized delay of 24 to 48 hours. This lag impedes real-time optimization efforts, as advertisers receive performance data well after user interactions occur. In fast-paced advertising environments, the inability to adjust campaigns promptly based on fresh data can result in inefficient spend and missed opportunities to capitalize on successful tactics.
On the other hand, the shift from user-specific to aggregated data under SKAdNetwork limits the depth of insights available to advertisers. Detailed analyses like cohort studies, user lifetime value assessments, and granular attribution models are no longer feasible.
The combination of targeting limitations and attribution challenges directly impacts advertising campaigns' return on investment (ROI). Without precise data, advertisers struggle to determine which campaigns are delivering the best results.
In response to these obstacles, many advertisers reallocated their budgets toward platforms and channels less affected by Apple's privacy changes. According to AppsFlyer, a YOY comparison between iOS and Android (Q1 2022 vs Q1 2021) showed that the gaming IAP loss was more than double on iOS than on Android following ATT and SKAN implementation7. This demonstrates how reliant games are on marketing and user-level data signal-based optimization.
Adapting to SKAdNetwork requires advertisers to rethink their campaign structures. Simplifying campaigns by reducing the number of variations can help mitigate the limitations imposed by SKAdNetwork's cap on campaign IDs. Focusing on creative excellence becomes crucial; with less granular targeting, compelling ad creatives can significantly influence user engagement. Testing different messages and visuals within the allowed parameters can lead to better performance despite the constraints.
Leveraging aggregated data effectively is also key. Advertisers can identify which campaigns or creatives resonate with audiences by analyzing broader trends rather than individual user behaviors. This shift encourages a more holistic approach to performance measurement, focusing on overall campaign impact rather than user-level interactions.
Apple's Private Click Measurement (PCM) offers a way to attribute clicks without compromising user privacy. PCM enables the tracking of ad clicks that lead users from an app to a website or vice versa, without revealing personal data. Implementing PCM involves:
First-party data, information collected directly from users with their consent, has become increasingly valuable. By strengthening direct relationships with users, companies can gather insights without relying on third-party tracking. Strategies include:
Securing user consent for tracking hinges on transparent communication about the benefits. To encourage opt-ins:
Some apps have reported higher opt-in rates when effectively communicating these benefits, indicating that users are willing to grant permission when they see clear value.
With reduced access to user-level data, contextual advertising has re-emerged as a powerful strategy. Instead of targeting users based on their past behavior, ads are placed in contexts relevant to the product or service. This involves:
Contextual advertising offers several advantages:
Industry studies have shown that contextually relevant ads can improve brand recall and purchase intent, demonstrating the effectiveness of this approach in driving meaningful engagement.
By embracing these strategies, advertisers can adapt to the evolving landscape shaped by Apple's privacy initiatives. Focusing on creative excellence, leveraging first-party data, and adopting contextual advertising not only align with privacy standards but also open new avenues for effective user acquisition.
With Apple's enhanced privacy measures reshaping the advertising ecosystem, advertisers and developers must pivot to new strategies that respect user privacy while still achieving their marketing objectives. The shift away from user-level data necessitates innovative solutions that can provide actionable insights without compromising personal information. This section explores alternative tools and methodologies that have emerged to navigate these challenges, enabling businesses to adapt and thrive in a privacy-centric environment.
In response to the limitations imposed by Apple's App Tracking Transparency (ATT), several third-party companies have developed aggregated measurement tools that comply with Apple's privacy guidelines. These solutions aim to provide valuable insights while respecting user privacy by avoiding the collection of personal identifiers like the IDFA.
Notable tools include:
Steps to implement and maximize the benefits of aggregated measurement tools:
Predictive analytics involves using historical data, machine learning algorithms, and statistical models to forecast future outcomes. In the context of limited access to user-level data, predictive modeling becomes a powerful tool to infer user behavior and guide marketing strategies.
Applications include:
Limitations:
Best Practices:
Mobile Measurement Partners (MMPs) have long been essential in helping advertisers attribute app installs and in-app events to specific campaigns. With the introduction of ATT, MMPs have adapted their services to continue providing value while complying with new privacy standards in several key aspects:
MMPs assist advertisers through:
The mobile advertising landscape has undergone a significant transformation due to Apple's introduction of App Tracking Transparency (ATT) and the shift from IDFA-based tracking to SKAdNetwork. Advertisers can't tap into individual user data like before, which changes how they find audiences, track results, and calculate returns. It's a hurdle, sure, but it's also a chance to get creative and make user privacy a top priority.
Now more than ever, staying flexible in how you attract new users is key. When your campaigns can adjust on the fly to new rules or tech changes, you stay ahead of the game. Putting transparency and user data protection first doesn't just comply with policies. It builds trust. And that trust turns into strong, lasting relationships that are worth their weight in gold.
Navigating these complex changes doesn't have to be daunting. GameBiz Consulting specializes in helping businesses like yours adapt to the evolving mobile advertising landscape. Our expertise in user acquisition and deep understanding of the latest industry shifts enable us to optimize your ad spend for the best results.
Contact GameBiz Consulting today to learn how we can help you overcome challenges, seize new opportunities, and achieve your marketing goals in this new era of privacy-focused advertising.
Sources:
